Selecting an Audit Firm

If there is an audit committee, one of its primary responsibilities is to select an auditor who has the expertise and knowledge to perform an audit for a tax-exempt charitable nonprofit. (If there is no audit committee then the responsibility to recommend the retention of an auditor may fall to the executive director and the full board.) Before meeting with CPAs and/or audit firms, the audit committee should develop goals and objectives to help narrow the search to only those CPAs and/or audit firms that have the skills and experience to provide the services your organization needs. It is essential to make sure the CPA or audit firm is licensed in your state!

When it’s time to find a CPA or audit firm for your charitable nonprofit

• Check with other professional service providers and organizations similar to your own for recommendations on CPAs and/or audit firms.
• Not all auditors have nonprofit experience, so you should check references and ask for a copy of their Peer Review (most states require auditors to be audited themselves by a third party, which is called a "peer review").
• Before you decide on an auditor, do enough due diligence to know whether there are any conflicts of interest. Don't forget to check with your board members as part of that investigation.
• Sometimes free consultations can be an opportunity to interview potential CPAs or audit firms. 
• Don’t hesitate to ask for references and/or resumes of individual CPAs within larger firms.
• Look for a CPA or auditing firm that understands accounting for charitable nonprofits and has expressed interest in your mission. Be sure to ask how the CPA or firm will educate your staff on how to prepare for the audit since that will be the most time-consuming process for your staff, and can most directly impact the time it takes for the auditors to investigate and complete their report. This is where the nonprofit can help control some of the costs of the audit!
• Research organizations that represent the accounting profession in your state, such as your State Board of Accountancy, to help you determine how to evaluate the CPA/audit firm, based on standards that CPAs are expected to follow in your state. (Memberships in some professional associations require CPAs to adhere to certain ethical standards of service. For example, the American Institute of Certified Accountants requires its CPA members to follow its Code of Professional Conduct.)
• Use a “request for proposals” process. Request a proposal letter from qualified CPA firms. When requesting a proposal for audit services, the objectives and scope of the audit should be clear. Ask them to meet with you, provide a quote, as well as their credentials and references. Be sure to ask for references from tax-exempt charitable organization clients.
• When evaluating a proposal for audit services, the audit committee should consider the following:
  
  1. The responsiveness to the request for proposal
  2. Relevant experience
  3. Availability of staff with professional qualifications and technical abilities
  4. The results of external quality control reviews
  5. References from other nonprofit clients, and
  6. Of course, costs.

Resources for choosing an auditor

• Sample Request for CPA Qualifications and Request for Proposal Letter from Qualified CPA Firms for their Services (AICPA)
• Sample Request for Proposal (RFP) for audit services (Raffa)
• How to purchase audit services (About.com)
• Choosing an External Auditor - While not intended for an audience of charitable nonprofits, this white paper contains very helpful information, especially in sections two and three about the RFP process and suggestions for the selection process. (Intergovernmental Audit Forum)
• RISKfacts: Outside Advisors – Selecting and Using Accounting and Insurance Experts (Charity First)

Conflicts of interests and auditor independence

Inevitably staff members are involved in the audit field work and in preparing the documents that are reviewed by the auditors. There is always the potential for a conflict in that staff are implementing the internal controls and because they are often the people with the most opportunity to mask financial irregularities.

The AICPA and the individual state governments require auditors to be independent. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires publicly traded companies to rotate lead auditors -- not necessarily audit firms -- every five years. While this provision of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002  does not apply directly to nonprofits, it is still a wise practice for a nonprofit to consider how to ensure that fresh eyes are periodically looking at its financial records. The rotation of the individual lead auditor periodically can ensure that the eyes of those examining the nonprofit’s financial records are fresh, and less likely to be overlooking something just because of a long-standing relationship with the nonprofit as a client. Auditor independence may also be compromised if the audit firm provides consulting services to a client-nonprofit, while at the same time performing an audit (or a financial review, or a compilation). (AICPA’s Code of Professional Conduct). As a result, it is considered “best practice” to refrain from engaging the same individual or firm for both auditing and non-auditing services (other than filing their IRS annual reports, such as the IRS Form 990). This will help avoid conflicts of interest.

Remember that CPAs and auditing firms work with their clients to improve financial practices and ensure accountability. In this sense, they are responsible to the public as well as to their clients. Therefore, CPAs and auditing firms, as licensed professionals with their own professional code of conduct and regulations, are charged with remaining independent and objective, regardless of the level of financial review they provide to the nonprofit client.

Resources

• Nonprofit Auditor-Selection Guide
• Independence and Conflicts of Interest (AICPA)
• AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (AICPA)
• Rule 102-2 Conflicts of Interest (AICPA)